Welcome to Discussion Essays!
By the end of this lesson, you will be able to:
- Identify discussion essay questions correctly
- Present BOTH views fairly and equally
- Use neutral language to discuss different perspectives
- Decide where to place your opinion (if asked)
- Use effective contrasting language
- Write a balanced, well-structured discussion essay
What is a Discussion Essay?
A discussion essay asks you to explore both sides of an argument before (usually) giving your own opinion. Unlike opinion essays where you argue for ONE side, discussion essays require you to:
โ Present View A fairly
Explain the first perspective with reasons and examples, using neutral language.
โ Present View B fairly
Explain the opposite perspective equally well, also with neutral language.
โ Give your opinion (if asked)
State which view you support, or find middle ground - but only if the question asks for your opinion!
| Opinion Essay | Discussion Essay |
|---|---|
| Take ONE side strongly | Discuss BOTH sides fairly |
| Both body paragraphs support your view | Each body paragraph covers a different view |
| Opinion throughout entire essay | Neutral until opinion section (if asked) |
| Use persuasive language | Use neutral, balanced language |
Why Discussion Essays Are Challenging
- โ Writing more about one view than the other (unbalanced)
- โ Giving opinion too early (should stay neutral in body paragraphs)
- โ Only discussing one side properly
- โ Confusing it with an opinion essay
- โ Not answering both parts of the question
- โ Using biased language when presenting views
- โ Both views discussed equally (similar length)
- โ Neutral tone when presenting each view
- โ Good reasons and examples for both perspectives
- โ Clear opinion (if question asks for one)
- โ Effective use of contrast language
- โ Logical progression from view to view
How to Identify Discussion Essay Questions
Look for these phrases in the question:
- "Discuss both views and give your opinion"
- "Discuss both these views and give your own opinion"
- "Some people think... while others believe... Discuss both views"
- "Discuss both sides of this argument"
- "There are different opinions about... Discuss"
Practice: Identify the Discussion Questions
Click on each question card. Is it a DISCUSSION essay or something else?
Question 1
"Some people believe that parents should teach children how to be good members of society. Others believe this is the role of schools. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion."
Question 2
"Many people believe that social networking sites have had a huge negative impact on society. To what extent do you agree or disagree?"
Question 3
"Some people think that universities should provide graduates with the knowledge and skills needed in the workplace. Others think that the true function of a university is to give access to knowledge for its own sake. Discuss both views and give your opinion."
Question 4
"In many countries, the quality of life in large cities is becoming worse. What are the causes of this problem? What measures can be taken to solve it?"
Question 5
"There is a debate about whether traditional teaching methods are better than modern technology-based learning. Discuss both views and give your opinion."
Question 6
"Some people believe that studying abroad has more advantages than disadvantages. Do you agree or disagree?"
Discussion Essay Structure
Most Band 7+ discussion essays follow this proven structure:
1๏ธโฃ Introduction (3-4 sentences, ~50 words)
- Hook/Context: Introduce the general topic
- Present both views: Briefly mention the two perspectives
- Thesis: State that you will discuss both views (+ opinion if asked)
"The role of education has become a subject of debate. While some believe universities should focus on practical job skills, others argue for academic knowledge. This essay will discuss both perspectives before presenting my view that a balance is necessary."
2๏ธโฃ Body Paragraph 1 - First View (5-7 sentences, ~90 words)
- Topic sentence: Introduce the first viewpoint (neutral tone)
- Explanation: Why do people hold this view?
- Example/Evidence: Support with specific example
- Further development: Extend the argument
- Concluding sentence: Summarize this perspective
- Start: "On the one hand..." / "Those who support X argue that..."
- Stay neutral: "They believe..." / "This view holds that..."
- Use objective language throughout
3๏ธโฃ Body Paragraph 2 - Second View (5-7 sentences, ~90 words)
- Topic sentence: Introduce the opposing viewpoint (neutral tone)
- Explanation: Why do people hold this alternative view?
- Example/Evidence: Support with specific example
- Further development: Extend the argument
- Concluding sentence: Summarize this perspective
- Start: "On the other hand..." / "However, others contend that..."
- Use contrasting language: "Conversely..." / "In contrast..."
- Maintain neutrality
4๏ธโฃ Conclusion (2-3 sentences, ~40 words)
- Summarize both views briefly: Recap the two perspectives in one sentence
- State your opinion (if asked): Which view do you support, or do you see merit in both?
- Final thought (optional): Broader implication or recommendation
1. Choose a side: "While both views have merit, I believe that..."
2. Balanced view: "In my opinion, the most effective approach combines elements of both perspectives..."
Introduction: ~50 | Body 1: ~90 | Body 2: ~90 | Conclusion: ~40
Alternative Structure (5 Paragraphs)
- If View A has two distinct arguments worth separating
- If View B has two distinct arguments worth separating
- If the question explicitly mentions multiple reasons for each view
โ ๏ธ However, 4 paragraphs is generally safer and easier to balance!
โ๏ธ Balance Checker Tool
For high Task Response scores, examiners want to see EQUAL discussion of both views. If one paragraph is 40 words and the other is 120 words, your score will suffer. Use this tool to check your balance!
Check Your Paragraph Balance
Paste your two body paragraphs below to see if they're balanced:
Balance Analysis
- Perfect Balance: Within 10 words of each other (e.g., 95 words vs. 90 words) โ
- Acceptable Balance: Within 20 words (e.g., 95 words vs. 75 words) ๐
- Slightly Unbalanced: 20-30 word difference (try to improve) โ ๏ธ
- Unbalanced: More than 30 word difference (will hurt your score) โ
- Plan both paragraphs before you write
- Give equal time (and thought) to each view
- Provide examples for BOTH perspectives
- Use the same sentence structure (Topic โ Explain โ Example โ Link)
- Count words/sentences as you write
- In planning, write the same number of ideas for each view
๐ฌ Essential Language for Discussion Essays
1. Presenting the First View
Formal, common opening
Neutral attribution
General, neutral
For specific groups
Passive, formal
Alternative opening
2. Transitioning to the Second View (Contrasting)
Most common transition
Clear contrast
Formal opposite view
Showing difference
Presenting option 2
Despite previous view
3. Neutral Language (Don't Show Bias!)
4. Giving Your Opinion (In Conclusion)
Direct, clear
Personal stance
Acknowledging both first
Formal opinion
Assertive but respectful
Softer opinion
5. Balanced Conclusion Phrases
- "The ideal solution lies in combining elements of both approaches..."
- "Rather than choosing one view over the other, I believe..."
- "Both perspectives offer valuable insights, and the best approach is..."
- "While X has merit in certain contexts, Y is more suitable for..."
- "A balanced approach that incorporates both views would..."
๐ก Where Should You Place Your Opinion?
Choose Your Structure
Decision Flowchart
โ Question says "give your opinion"
โ You MUST give your opinion
Choose Option 1 or 2 (safest: Option 1)
โ Question only says "discuss both views"
โ Opinion is optional (but recommended)
Brief opinion in conclusion shows critical thinking!
โ Not sure which to use?
โ Use Option 1 (opinion in conclusion only)
This is the safest, most balanced approach for Band 7+
"I don't care WHEN you give your opinion, as long as:
- โ You discuss BOTH views fairly and equally first
- โ You actually give an opinion (if the question asks for one)
- โ Your opinion is clear and supported
- โ The essay maintains logical organization
โญ Band 8 Model Essay
"Some people think that parents should teach children how to be good members of society. Others believe that school is the place to learn this. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion."
Band 8 Discussion Essay
Introduction
The question of who should be responsible for teaching children social values has become increasingly debated in modern society.
While some argue that parents are primarily responsible for this education, others maintain that schools should play this role.
This essay will examine both perspectives before arguing that a combination of both approaches is most effective.
Body Paragraph 1 - First View (Parents' Role)
On the one hand, those who support parental responsibility argue that families provide the foundation for social development.
They believe that children learn fundamental values such as respect, honesty, and kindness primarily through observing and interacting with their parents from a very young age.
For instance, a child who witnesses their parents treating others with courtesy is more likely to internalize these behaviors than one who only encounters such lessons in a classroom setting.
Furthermore, parents have the advantage of being able to provide consistent guidance throughout daily life, reinforcing positive behaviors in real-world contexts rather than through abstract instruction.
This view holds that the intimate, ongoing nature of family relationships makes parents the most effective teachers of social conduct.
Body Paragraph 2 - Second View (Schools' Role)
On the other hand, advocates of school-based social education present equally compelling arguments.
They contend that schools provide structured environments where children can learn to interact with diverse peers and authority figures, which is essential for functioning in broader society.
For example, through group projects and classroom activities, students develop crucial skills such as cooperation, conflict resolution, and respect for different viewpoints that may not emerge within a homogeneous family unit.
Moreover, professional educators are specifically trained in child development and social pedagogy, potentially offering more systematic and informed approaches than parents who rely primarily on their own upbringing.
From this perspective, schools serve as vital training grounds for the social competencies required in modern, diverse societies.
Conclusion
While both parents and schools can effectively teach social values, each with their distinct advantages,
I believe that the most successful approach combines both influences.
Parents provide the emotional foundation and consistent modeling, while schools offer structured opportunities for practice in diverse social contexts, making collaboration between these two institutions essential for raising well-adjusted citizens.
๐ฏ Why This is Band 8:
| Criterion | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Task Response | 8 | Both views discussed equally and thoroughly; clear opinion given; all parts addressed |
| Coherence & Cohesion | 8 | Perfect essay progression; excellent use of contrast language; clear paragraphing |
| Lexical Resource | 8 | Sophisticated vocabulary (internalize, pedagogy, homogeneous); precise word choice; natural collocations |
| Grammar | 8 | Wide range of complex structures; error-free throughout; varied sentence forms |
- Introduction: 3 sentences, 46 words
- Body Paragraph 1: 5 sentences, 94 words (Parents' view)
- Body Paragraph 2: 5 sentences, 93 words (Schools' view) โ Perfect balance!
- Conclusion: 3 sentences, 54 words
- Total: 287 words
โ๏ธ Practice Writing
Write a complete discussion essay on the question below. Use the structure we learned and aim for 270-290 words.
Practice Question:
"Some people believe that the best way to reduce crime is to give longer prison sentences. Others believe that there are better alternative ways to reduce crime. Discuss both views and give your opinion."
Type: Discussion Essay | Time: 40 minutes | Target: 270-290 words
Step 1: Planning (5 minutes)
Step 2: Write Your Essay
Introduction
Body Paragraph 1 - First View (Longer sentences)
Body Paragraph 2 - Second View (Alternative methods)
Conclusion (Include your opinion!)
๐ Essay Statistics
Total Word Count: 0 words
Balance Check:
Body 1: 0 words | Body 2: 0 words